Do Natural Diamonds Hold Value?

Diamonds have long been seen as symbols of love, luxury, and success. For centuries, people have bought them not only as jewelry but also as family heirlooms and, in some cases, as investments. But in today’s world of changing markets and new alternatives like lab grown diamonds, one question often comes up: do natural diamonds hold value?

The short answer is yes—but with important conditions. Let’s explore what affects diamond value, how natural stones compare to lab grown, and what buyers should keep in mind before purchasing.

The Rarity of Natural Diamonds

Natural diamonds are formed deep in the earth under high pressure and high temperature over billions of years. Their rarity is a key reason they are valuable. Unlike lab created diamonds, which can be produced in a matter of weeks, natural diamonds are finite. Once mined, no more of the same stones can be replaced.

This scarcity has allowed natural diamonds to retain cultural and financial value over generations. Families often pass them down as heirlooms, and jewelers continue to prize them as the standard for engagement rings and fine jewelry.

Resale Value: What to Expect

When people ask if diamonds hold value, they usually mean resale value. It’s important to understand how this works.

• Retail vs resale: A diamond bought at retail includes markups for branding, marketing, and craftsmanship. When reselling, buyers usually only pay for the stone’s wholesale value. That means you may not get back the full price you originally paid.
• Market demand: Classic shapes like round and oval often resell better than less popular cuts. Larger stones also tend to hold value more strongly.
• Quality matters: Diamonds graded higher in the 4Cs—carat, cut, color, and clarity—retain more value because they are rarer and in greater demand.

While resale prices are typically lower than retail prices, natural diamonds generally hold more value than their lab grown counterparts.

Natural Diamonds vs Lab Grown Diamonds

In recent years, lab grown diamonds have become popular because they cost 40–60% less than natural stones of similar size and quality. However, they do not hold value the same way.

• Natural diamonds: Resale markets exist worldwide. Jewelers, dealers, and auction houses are willing to buy them, often at strong prices if quality is high.
• Lab grown diamonds: Technology continues to make production cheaper, which lowers resale value. In many cases, sellers find little to no secondary market for lab grown stones.

For buyers looking at long-term significance—whether financial or emotional—natural diamonds remain the stronger choice.

Factors That Influence Diamond Value

Several elements affect whether your natural diamond will hold value over time:

1. Certification – A diamond graded by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) carries more credibility. Certificates prove authenticity and reassure buyers of quality.
2. Carat size – Larger diamonds are rarer and tend to keep value better. A 2-carat natural diamond, for example, often resells more easily than a 0.5-carat stone.
3. Cut quality – A well-cut diamond shines brighter and commands more demand.
4. Color and clarity – Stones closer to colorless (D-F) and with fewer inclusions hold value better.
5. Market trends – Diamond values can rise or fall depending on global demand, currency exchange rates, and fashion preferences.

Diamonds as Investments

While natural diamonds hold value, they should not be viewed the same way as stocks or real estate. They are not highly liquid assets, and selling quickly may mean accepting lower offers.

However, diamonds do provide emotional and generational value. A natural diamond engagement ring or necklace can be passed down for decades, carrying both financial worth and family meaning. This dual value—sentimental and monetary—is one of the reasons natural diamonds remain in demand.

How to Protect the Value of Your Diamond

If you want your natural diamond to maintain value, follow these steps:

• Keep certification: Store your GIA or IGI report safely—it adds trust and resale power.
• Choose timeless designs: Classic cuts and settings tend to hold demand better than trendy styles.
• Insure your jewelry: Protect against loss or theft so your investment is secure.
• Maintain condition: Regular cleaning and prong checks prevent damage that could reduce value.

Do Natural Diamonds Appreciate?

In some cases, yes. Rare and exceptionally large natural diamonds have appreciated significantly, especially when sold at auction. However, most consumer-grade diamonds maintain rather than grow in value. Their strength lies in preservation of worth and heritage, not quick financial gains.

For most buyers, the question is less about profit and more about security. A natural diamond bought today is far more likely to be resellable in the future than a lab grown stone.

Book a Diamond Appointment 

So, do natural diamonds hold value? Yes—but with realistic expectations. Natural diamonds are rare, finite, and culturally significant, which allows them to keep more value than lab grown alternatives. However, resale often means receiving less than retail price due to market dynamics.

Still, natural diamonds remain powerful symbols of love, family, and permanence. Their true value lies not only in dollars but in the stories they carry across generations. For those seeking jewelry that lasts both in beauty and worth, natural diamonds continue to shine as the most reliable choice.

Ready to experience the brilliance of a natural diamond in person?

Book a Diamond Appointment  with our experts and let us help you find the perfect natural diamond for your engagement.